The Sweet Secret Behind a Bakery Favorite from the 1930s
I may earn a commission if you click on a link and buy something.
In this episode, Kathie welcomes Tiffany from Well Fed Baker to share the heartfelt story of her great-grandfather’s butter rolls — a beloved recipe that’s been delighting family and strangers alike since the 1930s in Cascade, Idaho.
Tiffany’s great-grandfather ran a small-town bakery where these butter rolls became legendary, drawing in locals and travelers who insisted they were a “must-try.” Now, generations later, the recipe is still made lovingly by family members — often in big batches for holidays, gatherings, and “just because” weekends. Tiffany recalls learning to bake them alongside her grandmother and how the rolls evolved over the years, even inspiring experiments like rum-soaked dried fruit, apple pie toppings, and sandwiching frosting between halves for less mess.
Though Tiffany can no longer eat the original rolls due to celiac disease, she’s working on a gluten-free version — a project of love, memory, and persistence. The episode is full of tips for working with yeast dough, stories of food as family glue, and permission to experiment in your own kitchen, imperfectly and joyfully.
Notable Quotes from the Episode
- “It’s been almost a hundred years since he opened his bakery, and we’re still talking about these rolls.”
- “Sometimes the memory of food is harder to recreate than the flavor.”
- “It’s a beautiful, rich dough… Not fussy, but forgiving. The kind that invites you to slow down and stay home.”
Where to Find Tiffany
The Original Recipe: Charlie’s Butter Rolls
Tiffany’s Blog: Well Fed Baker